We're thrilled to announce the return of GamesBeat Next, hosted in San Francisco this October, where we will explore the theme of «Playing the Edge.» Apply to speak here and learn more about sponsorship opportunities here. At the event, we will also announce 25 top game startups as the 2024 Game Changers. Apply or nominate today!
Starfield's design director says the game nearly had a voiced protagonist, but they dropped it: 'It was a AAA thing'
29.08.2023 - 15:11 / pcgamer.com / Emil Pagliarulo
In Polygon's recent interview with design director Emil Pagliarulo, it was revealed that Starfield very nearly had a voiced protagonist in the style of Fallout 4's sole survivor.
When asked whether this choice was a response to the fan reception of that game's controversial dialogue system—which only gave you the general vibe of what you were committing to words—Pagliarulo responded: «Not directly, but it certainly played into it … in pre-production, the plan was to have a voiced protagonist. We hired an actor, we got the voice, we listened to him and we were like, You know what, this guy is too specific.
»[In Starfield,] you can make every different type of person. We realised that the only way to really do [that] and let the player be the person they want to be was to have an unvoiced protagonist."
While we've obviously known your space explorer would be a silent protagonist since last year, I'm surprised we even came close to Fallout 4 setting a new blueprint for the Bethesda hero. I've always preferred knowing exactly what my character's going to say in a conversation—and having the word «Sarcastic» next to a button prompt doesn't clue me in enough. To me, it seemed like a weird love affair from big-budget studios, an attempt to come across as more 'cinematic' while shuttering an RPG's more freeform potential.
That's a sentiment Pagliarulo speaks to: «There was a time in the industry where every protagonist was voiced. It was a AAA thing … In Fallout 4 and other RPGs, players don’t like reading a line of dialogue (a player response), and then they click it and get [a different spoken line].»
He goes on to point out that hearing a character speak a line of text you've just read isn't ideal, either, «So then we just arrived at, What if we just go text? and it was just really freeing … it was not having a voiced protagonist that allowed us to create such a big world.»
It does seem that, mercifully, the modern RPG's obsession with fully voice-worked protagonists is mostly over. Don't get me wrong—I think it can be done well when said character's meant to have a baseline personality of their own. Commander Shepard's a good example—every Shepard is different, sure, but they share the same crew, general occupation, and responsibilities in the Mass Effect universe.
Similarly, Star Wars: The Old Republic has some great voiced protagonists—though they're tailored to the kind of story you sign up for at character creation.
But I don't think voiced protagonists were ever a good fit for the kind of RPG Bethesda tends to make—big, open worlds powered by player choice and freedom. Granted, in Fallout, every character starts off as a vault dweller. But from there, they can become almost anything, anyone—saddling
The website gametalkz.com is an aggregator of news from open sources. The source is indicated at the beginning and at the end of the announcement. You can send a complaint on the news if you find it unreliable.
Top Authors
Popular Topics
pcgamer.com
15.09.2023 / 00:57
Every Starfield player should use these 3 essential mods
Starfield guide: Our hub of adviceStarfield console commands: Every cheat you needStarfield mods: Space is your sandboxStarfield traits: The full list, with our top picksStarfield companions: All your recruitable crewStarfield romance options: Space dating
gameinformer.com
14.09.2023 / 19:17
Supergiant Games Announces Hades II Early Access Starts Next Year
Supergiant Games, the company behind Hades and Bastion, has revealed that it will launch Hades II into Early Access in the second quarter of 2024 on PC via Steam and the Epic Games Store. The company stopped short of revealing a concrete date, though.
gamesradar.com
14.09.2023 / 11:27
As Starfield shooters show off their most OP guns, players are sharing their hints about how to find the game's most busted weapons
After one Starfield player stumbled upon a seriously overpowered gun, other players are giving out tips on how to find busted weapons.
techradar.com
13.09.2023 / 09:49
Unity’s plans to charge per game install has developers begging gamers not to download their games
Yesterday (Tuesday, September 12), it was announced that the game engine Unity will soon begin charging developers a monthly fee based on the number of installs their games have, in a move that has left many indie studios upset and frustrated.
pcgamer.com
12.09.2023 / 21:05
Bethesda 'talked about' using the Fallout version of Earth in Starfield, Todd Howard says
For reasons I won't get into here because it may constitute a little bit of a spoiler, the planet Earth in Starfield is a bit of a wasteland. But what if it was The Wasteland—that is, the post-nuclear hellscape of Bethesda's other big sci-fi-ish game series, Fallout? In an interview with The Washington Post, creative director Todd Howard said developers actually gave thought to the idea.
gamesradar.com
12.09.2023 / 12:01
A week after release, Starfield players are sharing their must-know tips for the RPG
It's only been a week since Starfield fully released, but some players have experienced enough to share their tips for others just getting started in the RPG.
techradar.com
11.09.2023 / 16:45
Todd Howard says that hundreds of plans for Starfield "went out of the window"
Starfield director Todd Howard has spoken about plans for the game that didn’t make the final cut, including the idea for a very neat Fallout reference.
gamesradar.com
11.09.2023 / 15:11
Wonka director teases Timothée Chalamet's singing voice, but says the movie isn't a musical
From what we've seen so far of Wonka, the origin story of Roald Dahl's eccentric chocolatier from Paddington director Paul King, it looks like it's set to be an all-singing, all-dancing extravaganza.
pcgamer.com
08.09.2023 / 21:11
Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag was pulled from sale on Steam and everyone got excited because they thought a remake was going to be announced, but Ubisoft says no, something's just broken
Very quietly and without warning, Assassin's Creed: 4 Black Flag was recently removed from sale on Steam. It's still listed, and you can still access it if you already own it, but new purchases aren't currently possible. The surprise shutdown sparked hope among some fans that Ubisoft might be working on a Black Flag remake—and maybe even that a surprise release could be in the offing. But Ubisoft says that's not actually the case, and that sales of Black Flag weren't intentionally halted. Something's just gone wrong.
techradar.com
08.09.2023 / 12:53
Starfield doesn’t have ground vehicles because they would have changed the game, director says
Starfield director Todd Howard has addressed the space RPG’s lack of ground vehicles and explained that the decision was made so that the developers could focus on on-foot exploration.
wccftech.com
07.09.2023 / 13:19
Starfield Director Says You Might Need to Upgrade Your PC, Talks Exclusivity Benefits and Controversial Ending
Starfield Director Todd Howard, the man behind The Elder Scrolls and the latest Fallout games after Bethesda acquired the franchise, is easily one of the most acclaimed video game designers in the industry. He received many personal awards, including the honor of being inducted into the AIAS (Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences) Hall of Fame six years ago for his many contributions to the industry. The following year, he got a similar 'Industry Legend' award at Gamelab Barcelona.