Redditors Discuss Why Total War Fans are Playing Rome 2 Instead of Pharaoh - Hardcore Gamer

12.10.2023 - 22:11 / hardcoregamer.com / Hardcore

In the dynamic world of strategy gaming, it’s not uncommon for older titles to reclaim the limelight when the newer ones fail to impress. Such is the case with Rome II and Pharaoh, two Total War titles that have sparked quite a discussion on the gaming community, as evident in this Reddit thread. Let’s delve into the reasons behind this interesting shift, highlighting insights from fellow Redditors.

Redditor u/swagpresident1337 pointed out the pricing disparity between Rome II and Pharaoh. While many gamers are eager to experience the ancient Egyptian world, the price tag on Pharaoh left them hesitant. As u/swagpresident1337 succinctly put it, “It’s boring as hell,” seemingly referring to the high cost.

User twitch870 made an astute observation regarding Pharaoh’s timing, suggesting that its release coincided with other notable gaming events, including Cyberpunk updates, making it a challenging period for a new release. Furthermore, the game received mixed reviews, indicating potential issues affecting its player base. As u/twitch870 pointed out, it may find more success after a price drop and some improvements.

Reddit user GuglielmoTheWalrus made an interesting comparison, likening Pharaoh to Total War: Attila, highlighting that Attila’s broader spectrum of factions and historical depth made it a more enticing choice. Pharaoh’s Bronze Age setting, despite its allure, lacks the diverse factions and epic warfare appeal of other time periods explored in the Total War franchise.

Redditor Maleficent-Spell9025 summed up the situation succinctly, asserting that Rome II still enjoys a stronger player base. As a testament to the enduring appeal of this classic title, it continues to attract strategy gamers.

Reddit user Condottieri_Zatara reminisced about the rocky launch of Rome II, reminding us that sometimes nostalgia plays a significant role in game choices. Despite its tumultuous beginnings, Rome II remains a beloved classic for many gamers.

Another point was raised by u/Marshal_Bessieres, who proposed that Medieval II, a title older than Rome II, might even surpass Pharaoh’s player count. It’s a testament to the enduring popularity of certain Total War games.

Redditors like u/Existing_Ad_8295 and u/monalba expressed their eagerness for sequels to beloved titles like Medieval II and Empire. Their comments mirror the general desire among the Total War community for a return to these iconic settings.

As the Reddit thread reflects, it’s clear that a variety of factors influence a game’s popularity and player base. Price, setting, historical context, and timing all contribute to the dynamic world of strategy gaming. While Pharaoh is undeniably appealing, Rome II’s long-lasting charm keeps it a top choice for